Monday, November 16, 2026

Book Review: "The New Jim Crow" by Michelle Alexander

The New Jim Crow (2010)
Michelle Alexander (1967)
377 pages

What has changed since the collapse of Jim Crow has less to do with the basic structure of our society than with the language we use to justify it. … We have not ended racial caste in America; we have merely redesigned it. (2)

In The New Jim Crow, lawyer and legal scholar Michelle Alexander explores the evolution of America’s racial caste, which she defines as a system of racialized social control that dates back to the earliest colonial settlements. After reviewing how it arose to support first the institution of slavery and then Jim Crow segregation, she shifts to her main thesis: how, in the wake of the civil rights movement successfully ending Jim Crow in the 1960’s, there began “a carefully orchestrated political campaign” (69) to institute dramatic changes to the US criminal justice system, with the deliberate intent of using mass incarceration as a method of maintaining the racial caste. In thoroughgoing detail, she explores the development, implementation and consequences of these policies.

Alexander opens by describing the racial caste’s origins in the system of slavery created in Jamestown in the mid-1600’s. She traces its entrenchment into America’s social, political and economic structures with the expansion and intensification of slavery up through to the US Civil War, and how, with the end of slavery and in response to Reconstruction, maintaining the racial caste “became the consuming passion for most white Southerners,” (34) leading to the development of Jim Crow segregation.

With the end of Jim Crow, groups deeply invested in the continued existence of a racial caste sought out a new structure for maintaining it. Recognizing that they could no longer rely on overtly racial laws, they settled on pursuing a War on Drugs that, Alexander argues, while officially designed as race-neutral, has in intent and practice led to a system of mass incarceration specifically targeting people of color. Over the balance of the book, she describes how changes to the criminal justice system since the 1980’s have “caus[ed] arrests and convictions for drug offenses to skyrocket, especially among people of color [with the result that] the United States now has the highest rate of incarceration in the world.” (7) As a consequence, “the American penal system has emerged as a system of social control unparalleled in world history.” (9)

She concludes with the broad outlines of what she feels is needed to undo the profound power and hold of the racial caste. In her suggestions, however, I would argue that she either misses or fails to mention a critical element her own narrative actually repeatedly reveals: the active role of a small elite in constructing and controlling the narrative that originally created and has since aggressively maintained the racial caste, as a means of increasing their own wealth and power.

But first: one can imagine many readers expressing skepticism at her thesis, along the lines of: well, only those guilty of a crime end up incarcerated and drug use is a crime, so the incarcerated only have themselves to blame – how does the War on Drugs constitute a new system of social control, a maintenance of racial caste, rather than simply being about crime prevention? Alexander spends the bulk of the book answering such doubts, demonstrating through detailed analysis how the carefully orchestrated changes put in place to create the New Jim Crow have specifically targeted people of color. Along the way, she repeatedly makes clear that nothing she presents should be construed as downplaying the dangers of drug use or the importance of combatting crime. Her point is rather that the War on Drugs was never actually focused on fighting drug use or crime, but rather on creating a system of

mass incarceration … designed to warehouse a population deemed disposable – unnecessary to the functioning of the new global economy – [and replacing] earlier systems of control [such as slavery and segregation, that were] … designed to exploit and control black labor. (22)


Over several chapters, she details the history of the War on Drugs: government manipulation of public sentiment to garner support for dramatic spending increases on drug enforcement; strategic provisioning of financial and military resources to state and local law enforcement to overcome their initial reticence at shifting from a focus on violent crime to drug use; the vitiating of previously sacrosanct civil rights rules through changes to laws and decisions in court cases that have freed law enforcement and the entire criminal justice system to pursue more aggressive drug enforcement; the building of a public consensus “that drug crime is black and brown” (135) despite government and private surveys showing “people of all races use and sell illegal drugs at remarkably similar rates” (123); the resulting mass incarceration of people of color, and particularly African Americans; and finally, the impact on communities (and the country more broadly) as significant numbers of African Americans become excluded from social benefits and disenfranchised as citizens.

What Alexander reveals through her analysis is jaw dropping – pulling away the veil of government propaganda and media acquiescence to expose the reality behind the War on Drugs. Every page, every detail she marshals makes evident the depth and breadth of the manipulation of the US criminal justice system as a platform for enforcing America’s racial caste. Citing just a few of the many points that give credibility to her thesis: “at the time [President Reagan] declared [the War on Drugs], less than 2 percent of the American public viewed drugs as the most important issue facing the nation” (62); from 1972 to 2010, “the prison population would more than quintuple,” (10) to over 2 million people, with a staggering “7.3 million people currently under correctional control” (127) – in prison, on probation, or on parole; “[t]he Supreme Court has allowed use of drug-courier profiles as guides for the exercise of police discretion” that include “traveling with luggage, traveling without luggage, … acting too calm, acting too nervous, … being one of the first to deplane, being one of the last to deplane, deplaning in the middle …” (90-91), basically allowing anyone to be stopped at any time; and, government agencies have reported

that white students use cocaine at seven times the rate of black students, use crack cocaine at eight times the rate of black students, and use heroin at seven times the rate of black students … that nearly identical percentages of white and black high school seniors use marijuana … that white youth aged 12-17 are more than a third more likely to have sold illegal drugs than African American youth … [and] that white youth were actually the most likely of any racial group or ethnic group to be guilty of illegal drug possession and sales [and yet] black men have been admitted to state prison on drug charges at a rate that is more than thirteen times higher than that of white men. (123-5)


And on, and on; nearly every page adds a damning brick to the case Alexander builds as she demonstrates how the unremitting War on Drugs has intentionally targeted African Americans, leading to a disastrous rise in their incarceration numbers and ultimately damaging consequences for both African American communities, and US society as a whole.

Having established the structure and impacts of this corrosive system of mass incarceration, Alexander offers thoughts on how to dismantle it. Already in the introduction, she makes clear the importance of pursuing a comprehensive solution:

If the movement that emerges to challenge mass incarceration fails to confront squarely the critical role of race in the basic structure of our society … the collapse of mass incarceration will not mean the death of racial caste in America. Inevitably a new system of racialized social control will emerge – one that we cannot foresee, just as the current system of mass incarceration was not predicted by anyone thirty years ago. (23) 

She returns to this sentiment in her final chapter, pointedly characterizing piecemeal reforms as insufficient to resolve the larger issue of the entrenched racial caste. Instead, she calls for “an honest conversation about race” that will “meaningfully address the racial divisions and resentments that gave rise to mass incarceration.” (320-1)

Hard to disagree with, as far as it goes. But she fails to identify a more fundamental, necessary first step that her own evidence reveals, and without which the conversation she pleads for will never be permitted to happen: curtailing the ability of the wealthy and powerful in the United States to dominate and control the narrative around race, in pursuit of their own interests. This they have done, as the following examples from Alexander’s work and other sources make clear, since the earliest settlements in what would become the United States.

Seeking to increase profits, plantation owners in 17th century Jamestown acquired more land by defining Indigenous populations as "a lesser race,” justifying “their extermination.” At the same time, their “growing demand for labor on plantations was met through slavery [of] Africans.” In the wake of Bacon's Rebellion in Jamestown in 1675, however, in which Nathaniel Bacon “managed to unite slaves, indentured servants, and poor working-class whites in a revolutionary effort to overthrow the planter elite,” these plantation owners “shifted their strategy for maintaining dominance” by taking

a step that would later come to be known as a 'racial bribe’ … extend[ing] special privileges to poor whites in an effort to drive a wedge between them and black slaves [to] eliminate the risk of future alliances between [them]. (29-31) 

Thus, to maintain slavery as a low-cost source of labor, Jamestown’s plantation owners and political leaders created and propagated the narrative of racial caste, one eventually formally enshrined in the US constitution.

Sociologist Tanya Golash-Boza, in Race and Racisms, makes similar arguments, noting that “once we understand that racial categories are not neutral but constructed, we can begin to think about why and how these categories were created.”  She describes how “in 1619, English colonists brought the first group of Africans to the North American colonies,” and notes that at first “[t]hese twenty Africans occupied nearly the same social status as European indentured servants,” with evidence “that these groups intermarried and fraternized.” Like Alexander, she identifies Bacon's Rebellion as the turning point that “led the elite to pass laws that divided black and white people.” By 1700, in Virginia,

50 wealthy families … depended on the labor of the other 40,000 colonists, [with the] imbalance of wealth making for a tenuous social order [in which] it soon became clear to the rich elite and the governing body that they could not continue to disregard the interests of the majority [of poor whites].

 In response, they enacted additional laws focused on “convincing poor whites that the rich landowners were not extremists or enemies, but protectors of their common interests as whites.”

In the wake of the outlawing of slavery after the Civil War, notes Alexander, wealthy and powerful whites sought new approaches for maintaining the racial caste, again as a means of securing a compliant labor force. Still driven by fear of interracial fraternization, they “concluded that it was in their political and economic interest to scapegoat blacks”:

Alarmed by … the apparent potency of the alliance between poor and working-class whites and African Americans … segregation laws were proposed as part of a deliberate effort to drive a wedge between them making it far less likely they would sustain interracial political alliances aimed at toppling the white elite … in effect, another racial bribe. (42) 

As a result, the Jim Crow segregation era began, in which

History seemed to repeat itself. Just as the white elite had successfully driven a wedge between poor whites and blacks following Bacon's Rebellion by creating the institution of black slavery, another racial caste system was emerging nearly two centuries later, in part due to efforts by white elites to decimate a multiracial alliance with poor people. (42-43)


History yet again repeated itself in the 1970’s, after the end of Jim Crow. Alexander notes that 

segregation had afforded elites a crucial means of exercising social control over poor and working-class whites as well as blacks. The Southern white elite, whether planters or industrialists, had successfully endeavored to make all whites think in racial rather than class terms, predictably leading whites to experience desegregation ... as a net ‘loss’. (319)

Seeking a new approach to maintaining the racial caste, and with the overt racism of segregation no longer acceptable, the elite landed on a ‘law and order’ message – ostensibly race neutral, but with intent and outcome very much focused on people of color. The political elite led the charge, as Republicans pursued a Southern strategy to create a new political majority, actively defining the necessary narrative:

some conservative political strategists admitted that appealing to racial fears and antagonisms were central to the strategy. … 

Republican strategist Kevin Phillips … argued … that Nixon’s successful presidential election campaign could point the way toward long-term political realignment and the building of a new Republican majority, if Republicans continue to campaign primarily on the basis of racial issues, using coded anti-black rhetoric. … [and] that [Southern white Democrat] voters could be easily persuaded to switch parties if those racial resentments could be maintained. (56-7) 

 A journalist noted that this “strategy largely depended upon creating and maintaining a racially polarized political environment,” (57) while another described the intentional “pitting of whites and blacks at the low end of the income distribution against each other.” (60) While this elite driven law-and-order campaign began during the Reagan administration, it continued under President George H.W. Bush, as a

surge of public concern [about drugs] did not correspond to a dramatic shift in illegal drug activity, but instead was the product of a carefully orchestrated political campaign. The level of public concern about crime and drugs was only weakly correlated with actual crime rates, but highly correlated with political initiatives, campaigns, and partisan appeals. (69)


Interesting, in the context of setting narratives, is Alexander quoting Frederick Douglass’s observation that “power concedes nothing without a demand; it never has and it never will.” (320) She makes it a description of the general “power” whites feel they have over blacks, but I would argue that the more important “power” is that of the elite, who have constructed and maintained the racial caste for their own purposes, by actively undermining the tendency of working-class whites and African Americans to see them as a common enemy.

Thus, in Alexander’s own text, the history of the US going back to the earliest colonies makes evident that dismantling the racial caste, and the system of mass incarceration that currently supports it, will remain a daunting task unless the country first addresses the ability of the elite to further their own interests by dictating the narrative sustaining such policies. And perhaps especially difficult because, as she notes, these elite are not necessarily themselves racist; rather, they simply seek wealth and power by whatever means necessary. “Not all plantation owners supported the institution of slavery because of a sadistic desire to harm blacks; most wanted to get rich, and black slavery was the most efficient means to that end.” (253) Centuries later, little has changed in that regard, with the consequence that an argument purely aimed at these elite as racist may have little effect.

Of course, the collaboration of the elite in tailoring the narrative in a way that maximizes the capital accumulation extends, in both time and place, far beyond the US context. In his engaging book Capitalism: A Global History, historian Sven Beckert provides striking evidence for the deeply intwined nature of the relationship between the state and capitalists:

Capitalism is as much a project of states as of capital owners…. Whether by supporting it in its day-to-day operations or during its most severe crises, states have propelled and backstopped the capitalist revolution through its history. (1076, Beckert) 

In particular, state and capital owners have pursued “commodification of labor across a spectrum of forms, ” including, “at key historical moments, slavery,” (20) and more generally sought to optimize social and economic controls for the benefit of capital. (My review of Beckert’s book linked to at right.)

And in that context, from both a global and US point of view, wrestling control over our social and economic narratives from the elite has added importance in light of a striking observation Alexander makes late in the book: unlike earlier manifestations of the racial caste, the current system of mass incarceration is "defined by marginalization,” as opposed to securing labor, and that

While marginalization may sound far preferable to exploitation, it may prove to be even more dangerous. Extreme marginalization, as we have seen throughout world history, poses the risk of extermination. (272) 

This takes on dramatically broader implications as we move into the age of AI, a decade after the book was originally published. In the coming age of AI, one can already observe the expectation of some among the elite that many workers may become marginalized. Yuval Noah Harari warns of exactly this future in his 21 Lessons for the 21st Century (my review linked to at right), noting that AI could lead to many people becoming irrelevant, “needed neither as producers nor as consumers.” (36-37, Harari) In the near future, keeping working class whites and African Americans from making common cause will be more important than ever for an elite focused on protecting their power and wealth.

Whatever the path to an eventual elimination of America’s racial caste however, in The New Jim Crow, Michelle Alexander provides a clear and powerful case for the role the War on Drugs has played in maintaining the profound hold of the racial caste system on American society since the end of Jim Crow. By situating the War on Drugs in the larger history of the origins of the racial caste some five centuries ago and the evolution of strategies for maintaining it since its introduction, she grounds her arguments in a firm foundation of historical fact. And, by bringing the data on page after page on the origins, evolution and impact of the War on Drugs and the resulting system of mass incarceration evidently targeting people of color, she makes a convincing argument for its role as a replacement, in spirit and in kind, for Jim Crow segregation.


Other notes and information:


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf