Saturday, September 1, 2018

Book Review: "Ice" by Anna Kavan

Ice (1967)
Anna Kavan (1901-1968)
193 pages


The narrator of Anna Kavan’s novel Ice describes a world on the brink of apocalypse, some unspecified scientific overreach having unleashed a wave of cold that threatens to bury the Earth under steadily advancing mountains of ice. He proves, however, to be undaunted by this spreading destruction and the dystopian world that results, as he doggedly pursues a girl who had captured his attention years before. Such is his preoccupation with this girl of his dreams that for him the collapse of the physical world, and with it civilization, only barely registers --- an inconvenience interfering with his pursuit.

He recalls his bitter disappointment when the girl left him in their youth for another man. In the intervening years, his disenchantment has transformed into a bipolar obsession for her that leaves him swinging wildly between deep concern for her well-being, and imagining her subjected to extreme violence. This internal confusion becomes apparent in his relationship with her: each time he finds her she rejects him so strenuously that he eventually gets fed up with her and leaves to get on with his life --- only to be helplessly drawn back to searching for her again, at seemingly any cost to his welfare or sanity.

The narrator complicates our understanding of these events already in the opening pages of the novel, however, giving us fair warning of his general unreliability: “Reality had always been something of an unknown quantity to me.” (4) A few paragraphs later he reveals that he was so impacted by the girl having left him that his “drugs prescribed for [headaches and insomnia have] produced horrible dreams … not confined to sleep only.” (6)

These nightmarish visions introduce a surreal aspect to the story, as they come upon him without warning. In the middle of describing some scene --- driving down the road, walking through a town or simply considering what to do next --- his description will suddenly descend, without warning, into a startlingly bleak and often violent subsequent sequence of events. Then, just as abruptly, he will shift back to the actual present and continue narrating his story, without any acknowledgement of the disturbing digression that has occurred.

Our only clue to his mind’s shifts from reality into “horrible dreams” is the sudden recognition of the outlandishness of what he is describing. The effect is very much like the tendency for a person’s thoughts to be suddenly derailed by concern about some potentially bad outcome to what is happening, eventually followed by a sudden snap back to reality. The difference lies in watching someone outside ourselves head down the rabbit hole, and the extreme desolation and brutality of the resulting hallucinations.

These visions impact not only his relationship with the girl, but also with a character known as the Warden, with whom the narrator finds himself grappling for much of the story. The leader of a small nation, the Warden has taken the woman in, and seems to have a profound dominance over her. Though the narrator and the Warden both express a desire to protect her, they also both infantilize and patronize the “girl”, as the narrator refers to her. At one point the Warden states coldly that “she only needs training … to be taught toughness, in life and in bed.” (153) For his part, the narrator rationalizes to himself that the girl in fact wants the awful treatment she receives, telling us: “Something in her demanded victimization and terror, so she corrupted my dreams, led me into dark places I had no wish to explore.” (82)

The narrator, despite his claimed aversion to being led to such “dark places [he] had no wish to explore,” more often seems to find pleasure in the fervid fantasies he has of the girl: “Like a perverted child she ran past, soliciting me with big eyes, tempting me with the pleasure of watching her pain, elaborating the worst imaginings of my desire.” (165) And, over the course of his repeated skirmishes with the Warden, from whom he is ostensibly trying to save the girl, the narrator even begins to identify with the Warden and his harsh treatment of her, saying at one point: “I suddenly felt an indestructible affinity with him, a sort of blood-contract, generating confusion, so that I began to wonder if there were two of us…” (85)

The girl herself barely has a voice in the story, and what little we do learn about her comes to us through a narrator of uncertain credibility. The men in the story who purport to have her best interests in mind show little concern for what she might be thinking or feeling or wanting. They use their own self-serving image of her as an excuse to treat her cruelly, rationalizing their resulting harshness as not only for her own good, but as what she in fact desires. Thus Kavan portrays the girl as little more than a pawn trapped in a misogynist nightmare.

After a bit of a slow start to establish the back story, and to introduce the narrator’s questionable hold on reality, the novel races ahead at a feverish pace. The surreal aspect of the narrator’s nightmarish visions pervade the novel, even those parts in which he has not apparently lost his hold on reality. Other than the Warden, Kavan gives no one a name or even title, and leaves the locations in the story vague and largely unidentifiable; in addition, whether in her descriptions of the disaster destroying the world, or her portrayal of the cat and mouse game between the narrator and the Warden, she presents the story with a kind of high contrast imagery. The result has a bit of a feel of the written equivalent of a glossy graphic novel.

Ice seduces a reader with the powerful force of the narrator’s fearsome obsession for the girl. Following him as he relentlessly pursues the girl through a disintegrating world leaves us with a powerful sense of vertigo, as we are forced to cling --- with the narrator --- to a tenuous and elusive reality.


Other reviews / information:


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Sunday, August 12, 2018

Book Review: "La uruguaya" ("The Uruguyan Woman") by Pedro Mairal

La uruguaya (The Uruguayan Woman) (2017)
Pedro Mairal
142 pages

Lucas Pereyra, the narrator of Pedro Mairal’s captivating novel La uruguaya (The Uruguayan Woman), leaves his home in the Argentinian capital of Buenos Aires early one Tuesday morning for a day trip across the La Plata river to Montevideo, Uruguay. A writer, he has been given advances to work on two new books, and in order to avoid paying stiff Argentinian taxes on this income he has had the money deposited by the publishers into a bank in Uruguay. His trip involves withdrawing the money, and smuggling it across the border into Argentina.

But already in the opening pages of his story of that day Lucas implies other, ulterior motives for his day trip to Montevideo, as, just before leaving the apartment, he describes giving “his kiss of Judas” (7) to his wife and young son. We soon learn that although his reasons for laundering the money through Uruguay are real, the process also serves him as the perfect cover for meeting up with the Uruguayan woman of the title, named Guerra, who has captured his heart though he’s only met her twice.

His day in Montevideo begins smoothly and according to plan with a successful visit to the bank to obtain his money, which he then carefully secures in a money belt he’s brought along. Once Lucas turns his attention to his rendezvous with Guerra however, rational thinking and behavior slip ever farther from his grasp, as he sinks into an intoxicating brew of hope and expectation for his afternoon with her. In Guerra, or more precisely --- given how little he knows about her --- in the carefully constructed Guerra of his imagination, Lucas finds not only a young woman who excites him, but also the perfect receptacle for his dreams of leaving behind an existence that he has come to perceive as a stifling burden.

At forty-four, Lucas has sunk into a mid-life crisis that has provoked a deepening melancholy. Having exhausted the money from his first published works, he bridles against the need to have his wife pay the bills and lend him money with the income from her job. And, as much he loves his son, he blames the quotidian responsibilities of childcare for his struggles to make progress in his writing. Desperate to escape these growing frustrations, he envelopes himself in fantasies about a potential carefree future with Guerra.

That he imagines leaving behind his wife and son for a woman he barely knows highlights the confusion and delusion that roils his mind. And in fact, as his day in Montevideo continues, he becomes ever more impulsive, aggressively sloughing off the occasional moments of clarity in which he questions the sanity of his actions. Even the complications that his evening deadline for returning home introduce into his impetuous attempts to woo Guerra only increase his distress, reinforcing his broader frustrations with the constraints of his present life.

With nothing solid to grab onto, each move he makes only leaves him more committed to his desperate path, but also more uncertain about it. Can he trust anything he thinks he knows? Can he distinguish whether he is passing through to a happier place, or a sliding into an abyss?

Mairal has structured the novel as a letter or confessional piece Lucas writes to his wife a year or so after the fateful day, in which he describes to her what occurred between his early morning departure to the moment of his return home to the apartment late that same evening. Through flashbacks, we --- and his wife --- learn how he first met Guerra, and get his understanding of the difficult times he and his wife had been experiencing. As he looks back on the day in Montevideo, Lucas can also not help but offer occasional foreboding hints at what the day holds for him, and its eventual ramifications on him, and his family.

By writing it using the first person voice, Mairal has given the story a powerful intimacy. And he does a wonderful job of portraying Lucas’ mental dissolution, first and foremost by making Lucas trustworthy as a narrator --- however confused and destructive Lucas’ thinking that day in Montevideo, it’s clear that by the time he writes about it, he has arrived on solid ground. His clear and pitiless evaluation of his behavior in hindsight, as he describes that fateful day, keeps him from coming across as a simple adulterer.

As readers we are torn between wanting to shake him out of the destructive behavior that threatens his family’s future, and sympathizing with him in his search for happiness with Guerra. La uruguaya provides a seductive and compelling, one-day exploration into the consequences of someone permitting the powerful emotions of existential confusion and hopelessness to hold sway over their decisions and actions.


Other reviews / information:

Read quotes from the book here.
The translation from the Spanish of those quotes, and the one used in the review, are mine.

Unfortunately, it does not appear that La uruguaya has been translated into English yet.


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Saturday, July 28, 2018

Book Review: "Aquí yacen dragones" ("Here There Be Dragons") by Fernando León de Aranoa

Aquí yacen dragones (Here There be Dragons) (2013)
Fernando León de Aranoa
196 pages


For his book Aquí yacen dragones (Here There be Dragons), Spanish director Fernando León de Aranoa has written a series of extremely short vignettes in which he exposes and explores a variety of human foibles and folly. Along the way he for the most part manages to avoid crossing the dangerously thin and often-times capricious line that, in works of this kind, separates the thought-provoking and profound from the cute and facile.

The 113 pieces in the collection range in length from several words to several pages, with most logging-in at a few tightly wound paragraphs. The themes vary widely, from ruminations on the hidden reality behind clichéd thinking we tend not to question, to examinations of the implications and motivations behind engrained behaviors we carefully avoid considering too deeply.

Representative of León de Aranoa’s approach in the book is Primer Amor (First Love), which tells the story of a man who decides after his wife’s death to search “for his first love[;] for the girl who, with stormy eyes, had made the earth shake under his feet so many years before.” (120) In the colorful yet delicate style evident throughout the book, León de Aranoa describes the teenagers’ brief moment of happiness together one summer vacation long before:
They dated for a week. They vowed to never split up, but September, which is cruel and knows nothing of lovers, returned them to the autumn of their respective cities. (120)
Now, having found out where she lives these many years later, the man travels to her city and sets himself up in a café across from her door, hoping to catch sight of her. When he eventually does, his reaction forces us to confront the complex and conflicted nature of our memories and expectations.

That story, in its final line, contains a surprising twist, a technique that appears repeatedly in the book, and which León de Aranoa uses to drive home the ways we tend to default to mental shortcuts, and become stuck in self-delusional thinking. Admittedly, a few of the longer pieces are little more than set-ups for a cute surprise ending, and several others are simply whimsical one-liners, such as Los Meteorólogos en el Ascensor (Weathermen in the Elevator): “What does the weatherman talk about when he doesn’t know what to say?” But the majority pass beyond the superficial, starting from the statement of commonplace ideas and emotions to explore their deeper complexity.

El Silencio (Silence), for example, opens with the observation that “it is surprising how some things that appear to be simple can contain so many nuances.” (43) León de Aranoa goes on to consider the wildly different meanings and implications that “silence” can have, depending on the context. In this story his observations don’t so much shock or surprise, as crystalize the concept:
It is not the same, the silence of lovers, which expresses itself through hands and caresses, as the silence of the routine of a marriage that has already broken down, though one ignores it, and it continues on. There is likewise a loving silence, and another one violent. The first silences words of affection, while the second hides threats and insults. (43)

While some pieces will resonate more than others for particular readers --- based on individual experiences and outlook --- others carry a broader social and political import. The Oración Del Migrante (Migrant’s Prayer), for one, speaks directly to a politically charged pre-occupation of our present age. It opens:
Patron Saint of Migrants, Powerful Virgin who lives on both sides of the border: guide my steps through deserts and fences, stop the current of the freezing river, warm its waters and extend your cloak over the barbed wire fences, so that my naked feet can walk over them without injury. … When my child takes the last breath of life on my lap, temper my rage with your serene glance. (93)
The complexity of the immigration debate, with thoughtful regulation of immigration subjected to exaggerated accusations across the political divide in which one side sees it as tantamount to a demand for ‘open’ borders and the other a demand for ‘closed’ borders, too often results in conversations that lose sight of the individual humanity of migrants desperate seeking a path to survival for themselves and their families; León de Aranoa’s prayer reminds us of these faces of those who suffer from our inability to move beyond the virulent polemic.
http://tertulia-moderna.blogspot.com/2013/10/book-review-children-of-days-by-eduardo.html

In a similar vein, the piece Oro (Gold) captures in a few paragraphs the long and powerful reach of historical events in the Americas, from the painfully enduring impact of colonization, to the legacy of often corrupt governments that arose out of subsequent independence movements. It tells of treasure that’s discovered in a Spanish galleon that sank in colonial times, of the several entities that claim ownership to it, and of the indigenous peoples that don’t even have the voice to lay a claim for it. In the story’s tone and viewpoint one discovers strong parallels to the amazing works of Eduardo Galeano, such as his books Children of the Days, and Mirrors. (Links to my reviews of these books are at the right.)http://tertulia-moderna.blogspot.com/2014/11/book-review-mirrors-stories-of-almost.html

By turns surprising, wry and profound, León de Aranoa’s collection of observations turns our view inward, forcing us to critically examine behaviors and ways of thinking that have often become so ingrained that we leave them unconsidered.


Other reviews / information:

Read quotes from the book here.
The translation from the Spanish of those quotes, and the one used in the review, are mine.

Aquí yacen dragones (Here There be Dragons) does not appear to have been translated into English. All translations in this review are mine, including the title.


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Thursday, July 5, 2018

Book Review: "Sal" by Mick Kitson

Sal (2018)
Mick Kitson
234 pages

He hadn’t started going in Peppa’s room then but I knew he would soon because he said he would and Peppa was ten and that was when he started on me. (2)
These bracing lines from the opening pages of journalist Mick Kitson’s debut novel Sal make devastatingly clear the disturbing home life faced by the book’s thirteen year-old narrator, Sal, and her sister, Peppa. These same pages, however, also introduce Sal as clear-eyed and steely-willed beyond her years, determined to protect her sister at truly any cost.

As the story begins, the two huddle together in a shelter they have built for themselves in the wilderness; it is one of their first nights on their own in the woods, and a cold October wind chills them to the bone. But Sal has come prepared; after making the decision in the spring to flee, she willingly endured further months of abuse in order to give herself time to carefully and thoroughly organize an escape. Learning survival skills from many hours of YouTube videos, and creatively obtaining a variety of the survival tools shown, she has meticulously prepared herself, creating an elaborate plan to be able to stay together with her sister, and give them the best possible chance to survive.

Leaving their home behind, Sal has led her sister up into the deep woods of a mountainous reserve in the Scottish highlands. And, benefitting from both her detailed preparation as well as some timely good fortune, the girls come to make a go of it, relishing the peaceful beauty of their new home as they try to put the lingering horror of their old one behind them.

And yet. Can even Sal’s best laid plans and stubborn determination carry them through the daunting realities of surviving in the woods?

Kitson uses flashbacks by Sal to reveal the disturbing home life the girls have left behind, as well as the details of their escape. Through these flashbacks, Sal attempts to process what she has experienced, and the implications of the actions she has taken to protect herself and her sister. But however dark and at times overwhelming these memories, the newfound feeling of control over their lives that she and Peppa experience in the woods creates a powerful elixir. Despite the profound uncertainties of the natural world, the juxtaposition of the peace they experience in the woods to the premeditated violence and chaotic uncertainty of their abandoned home provides a convincing foundation for believing that two adolescents can be willing and able to put up with the challenges they encounter in the life they construct for themselves in the mountains.

Sal’s voice and tone also help in this regard. Her every thought and action reflects the translation of her role as the sole responsible caregiver and protector of her sister from the dangers they had faced at home to the preferable but no less threating world of their mountain home. Sal remains constantly on guard, almost robotic in her focus, with seemingly every event she faces triggering memories of a YouTube video she learned from, or an answer to a question she had purposefully asked a teacher, during her months of preparation.

Certainly it is no coincidence that Kitson titled the book after its narrator: at its heart the novel tells the story of how a thirteen year old --- abused and with no one to turn to or trust for support --- becomes a kind of machine in order to survive, single-mindedly focused on protecting her sister from her fate. Sal meticulously regulates her emotions and reactions, to the point of deliberately allowing herself on occasion a specific amount of time to worry about her situation before getting on with the business at hand. Robbed of her childhood, but not her humanity, Sal’s love for her sister Peppa burns strong and bright, enabling her to overcome seemingly any obstacle.

How appropriate, then, that the jacket designer for the hardcover edition elected to draw Sal’s name in large, glowing, capital letters, set like a leviathan astride a mountain wilderness scene.


Other reviews / information:

Having set the book in Scotland, Kitson includes Scottish expressions that were generally unfamiliar to me, some of them a struggle to understand even from context --- who knew that ‘greeting’ can be used to mean ‘crying’? Having a smartphone nearby to use to look-up the definitions for these words when they come up can be handy.


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Saturday, June 16, 2018

Book Review: "Our Mathematical Universe" by Max Tegmark

Our Mathematical Universe: My Quest for the Ultimate Nature of Reality (2014)
Max Tegmark (1967)
421 pages

Evolution endowed us with intuition only for those everyday aspects of physics that had survival value for our distant ancestors, leading to the prediction that whenever we use technology to glimpse reality beyond the human scale, our evolved intuition should break down. (363)
This observation by physicist and author Max Tegmark comes toward the end of his book Our Mathematical Universe, but it could perhaps have served well as its epigraph, giving readers fair-warning of the strange and profoundly counter-intuitive predictions and hypotheses about our universe that he describes as arising out of the most important and consequential theories in physics from the past century.

Given, then, that one must abandon intuition at the door, and despite Tegmark’s best efforts to distill the essence of what, as he himself indicates, at most a handful of modern-day physicists in the world truly grasp, his book is not for the faint of heart. But those who take courage in hand and dive-in will be rewarded with an engaging, if wild, ride through the latest --- yes highly counter-intuitive --- conclusions being explored about the nature of our physical world.

As hinted at in the book’s subtitle, My Quest for the Ultimate Nature of Reality, Tegmark goes beyond reviewing the origins and implications of the theoretical physics he covers, to also describe his role as a physicist in the developments of the past half-century and the conclusions he has drawn from that work about the “nature of reality.” Thus, into his explanations of the science, he works in auto-biographical notes that provide insight into the often incremental nature of scientific development, as well as the complexity of the politics among physicists. Certainly his description of the heated debates and disagreements among proponents of differing understandings of the models physicists have proposed to describe our physical reality, and the seemingly strict demarcation between what is acceptable to discuss or even consider publicly --- and what is not --- put the lie to an idealized view of science as a purely objective discipline driven only by the data.

Tegmark makes clear that the hypothesis that he has developed over the past few decades about the “ultimate nature of reality,” and that he lays out in this book, does not yet enjoy much support among the physics community. He even includes an e-mail from a “senior professor” (243) that implores him to, basically, keep his crazy ideas to himself, and so avoid destroying his own career. But, as evidenced by the irreverent style in which Tegmark has written the book, he is not one to be easily diverted from following where he feels that the mathematics and physics --- and observational data --- lead him.

Before getting to his own hypotheses about the physical world in the third and final part of the book, however, Tegmark sets the stage by reviewing some of the latest understandings and debates of physicists.

The first part of the book, labeled Zooming Out, deals with cosmology --- our understanding of, as the opening chapter is titled, Our Place in Space. Tegmark begins by re-tracing humankind’s gradual discovery of the vastness of space, and Earth’s place in it. Up to his description of the model of the Big Bang the story will be largely familiar to most lay-readers of science, though Tegmark provides fascinating insights, from his vantage point as a physicist doing experimental and analytical work, into especially the recent period of testing of the validity of the Big Bang model.

Then comes time, however, for readers to buckle their seatbelts. After discussing some of the limitations of, and seemingly wildly unlikely coincidences required by the Big Bang model based on the latest data and analysis, Tegmark introduces inflation theory, which was first proposed by physicist Alan Guth. Examining Einstein’s theory of gravity, Guth found that among its implications one can conclude that “once upon a time, there was a tiny uniform blob of a substance whose density was very hard to dilute,” (100) that such a substance can undergo an explosion in which it grows exponentially in size without its density dropping, and that this expansion can continue forever.

Tegmark notes that inflation theory has been found to address many of the issues observed with the Big Bang model. More critically, however, a further consequence of inflationary theory is that it can be understood to imply the existence of multiple, parallel universes, defined cumulatively as a multiverse, a concept that plays a central role in the reminder of the book.

Each of these parallel universes, according to inflation theory, results from the occurrence of a Big Bang in a region of the inflationary space, an event which, in fact, leads to an end to inflation in that particular region. And, as a consequence of the inflation of space going on forever, an infinite number of such parallel universes can exist, each the result of a separate Big Bang, our own universe being one among them. Critically, given different initial conditions for each such Big Bang, history will play out differently in each of these parallel universes: the history in a universe parallel to our own will differ from our own history to the extent that the initial conditions of the Big Bang in that region of space differ from those of our own region’s Big Bang.

One mind-blowing implication of such an infinite number of parallel universes is that somewhere in space, in a universe parallel to ours, history can proceed exactly as in ours except that, say, I stop writing this review after this sentence for whatever reason; and, of course, the same can be said about the next sentence, and so on. Given an infinite number of such parallel universes then, all possible histories can be imagined to be playing out, unaccountably many of them including some version of ourselves.

Taken together, Tegmark defines this set of parallel universes, in which the laws of physics are the same across all of them but the history taught in each one is different, as the Level 1 multiverse.

He goes on to define a Level 2 multiverse as the equally infinite number of universes that have the same fundamental laws of physics as ours, but whose effective laws of physics --- the laws as they are experienced --- are different in that key parameters (for example, the number of time dimensions or space dimensions, or the mass of the electron) can take on different values. The result is an infinity of Level 1 multiverses, each with different effective laws of physics, each separated from the others by an eternally expanding space between them, and each, of course, itself containing an infinite number of universes.

Given the weirdness (a word Tegmark himself uses repeatedly) of these ideas, and that they will only get still weirder as one gets deeper into the book, it is perhaps useful at this point to step back and highlight a key point that Tegmark makes: the potential existence of the Level 1 and Level 2 multiverses is not a theory or an unsubstantiated proposal; instead, the possibility of their existence arises as an implication of the mathematics of Einstein’s theory of gravity. And the fact that “Einstein’s theory of general relativity has successfully predicted many things that we can observe … we consider it a successful scientific theory and take seriously also its predictions for things we can’t observe.” (124) As Tegmark goes on to point out: “you have to either accept all [of a theory’s] predictions, or you have to start over from scratch” (125) --- you can’t pick and choose the predictions you like. Of course, as he points out repeatedly, such an understanding has not stopped significant portions of the community of physicists from discounting the idea of the existence of multiverses.

The middle part of the book, entitled Zooming In, turns to the very small, providing a history of the work that led to the development of quantum mechanics, and its still hotly debated meanings and implications. Tegmark summarizes the important conclusion of quantum mechanics as that particles can have “properties both of traditional particles (they’re either here or there) and of waves (they can be in several places at once in a so-called superposition).” (183) This behavior of particles, he recalls, is described by the wavefunction, developed by Erwin Schrödinger.

One implication of the wavefunction is that a particle, or a superposition of many particles such as an object or person, can be in more than one place at one time. But physicists have had to grapple with the fact that a particular particle (or superposition of particles) appears in a particular place when observed --- that is, the wavefunction is said to “collapse” to being a particle located at one particular place. He notes that Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg settled on “a remarkably radical remedy that became known as the Copenhagen interpretation, [which said in part that] if something is not being observed, then its wavefunction changes according to the Schrödinger equation, but if it is being observed, then its wavefunction collapses so that you find the object only in one place.” (178)

Tegmark summarizes the concerns some physicists have had with the apparent arbitrariness of the Copenhagen interpretation, then states that “in 1957, Princeton grad student Hugh Everett III had proposed a truly radical answer [to these issues] involving parallel universes” (186). Everett proposed that the wavefunction never collapses, regardless of whether an observation is taking place. The implication of this, according to Everett, was that if the wavefunction shows two possible locations for the particle, then when an observation is made our universe splits, so that in one branch the particle is in one place, while in the other it’s in the other place. As Tegmark describes it: “In other words, parallel-universe splitting is happening constantly, making the number of quantum parallel universes truly dizzying.” (190). This (again infinite) set of parallel universes he defines as the Level 3 multiverse.

Having set the stage by describing modern day cosmology and its implication for the potential existence of Level 1 and Level 2 multiverses, and quantum mechanics and its implication for the potential existence of the Level 3 multiverse, Tegmark gets to the heart of his own thesis in the final part of the book, in which he introduces what he defines as the Level 4 multiverse.

To introduce the conceptual walk he followed to arrive at the idea of this new order of multiverse, Tegmark recalls that scientists have long wondered at the effectiveness of mathematics in describing the physical universe. As an explanation for this he proposes “the hypothesis that there exists an external physical reality completely independent of humans.” (267) As a consequence of accepting this hypothesis, Tegmark argues that “the hypothesis that our external physical reality is a mathematical structure” (267) follows unavoidably. And, as a further consequence, if space (that is, the entire inflationary space in which we live, containing the Level 1, 2 and 3 multiverses) is defined by a mathematical structure --- that is, by the set of fundamental laws of physics that apply in our universe, and by extension in our entire inflationary space --- then it follows that other spaces can exist that have other mathematical structures, with different fundamental laws of physics.

Thus, the Level 4 multiverse contains an infinite number of spaces, each fully described by a different mathematical structure.

Key to acknowledging the essential nature of the mathematical structure of our space, according to Tegmark, is to not allow what he refers to as the “baggage of language” to interfere with our understanding; we must recognize that the names we give things are only for our own convenience, and don’t imply or represent any inherent property of those things. Thus, a “ball” or a “star” are convenient names we use to describe objects that are actually groupings of particles fundamentally described by the mathematical relationships between the particles. More broadly, the entirety of reality, Tegmark argues, can be fully describe by a set of mathematical relationships, independent of the descriptions any particular observer may give them, and in fact independent of the existence of any observer.

He points out that some, perhaps many, of the mathematical structures in the Level 4 multiverse may not be capable of leading to life, in any sense that we can imagine it. And as other mathematical structures may lead to vastly different fundamental physical laws, it can also be that the multiverses that have been proposed to exist in our space (our mathematical structure) may not exist in these other mathematical structures, though at the same time other kinds of multiverses that we can’t imagine may be present.

Over several chapters, Tegmark goes on to examine the mathematical structure of our particular universe, to the extent it is currently understood, and more generally the implications of his hypothesis for the existence a multiverse of different mathematical structures. He discusses how his hypothesis can address some of the currently unresolved mysteries of our universe, including the implications for the concepts of time, randomness, and complexity, and why the fundamental laws of physics in our universe seem to be tuned just right to support life. He also addresses how his hypothesis could be tested and verified.

The book concludes with a chapter whose title, Life, Our Universe and Everything, recalls the title of the first book in Douglas Adams’ series, The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy: Life, the Universe and Everything. (“Our” universe for Tegmark, of course, instead of Adams’ “the” universe, because the very subject of Tegmark’s book is that we live in one universe among infinitely many.) In this final chapter, Tegmark examines the potential ways in which our universe could one day end, based on current understandings. He then focuses more directly on the future of life, and in particular what could destroy life as we know it --- from near-term threats such as a global pandemic, nuclear war or climate change, to more distant threats such as the death throes of our sun or the eventual collision of our Milky Way with the Andromeda galaxy. He concludes with a plea that we recognize what he feels may be the nearly unique gift of consciousness that humankind enjoys on “Spaceship Earth” (398), and the importance of dealing with the near-term problems that place the existence of our life as a species at risk.

The link to Douglas Adams reflects the style and approach Tegmark uses throughout the book. He includes a variety of references to popular culture, from the The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy to Star Trek and others. He also tells stories of his own experiences studying and working in the field of physics, to highlight the challenges of doing work in this highly competitive field, including the difficulties and risks of bucking the status quo. Though he occasionally goes into some details of the mathematics and physics, he generally relegates the most technical aspects to the footnotes, and so keeps the main text at a more descriptive level, using prose and helpful diagrams to make his points.

At times this almost folksy nature of his writing can seem to overly simplify the explanation, failing to highlight the importance of particular points. More than once I encountered a statement along the lines of ‘as we saw in the previous chapter…’ and when I referred back, it was a single line buried in a paragraph, one that hadn’t seemed particularly consequential on the first pass, and so the implications of which I had missed.

This is a minor quibble, however. In Our Mathematical Universe, Tegmark has provided an entertaining, engaging and profoundly fascinating exploration of the cutting edge of physics and its implications for our understanding of reality. In a tradition that goes back to the earliest human urge to understand and explain our physical world, we continue to learn that that which we can see occupies an ever smaller and less central part of our latest understanding of the whole of what is.


Other reviews / information:

http://tertulia-moderna.blogspot.com/2017/05/book-review-reality-is-not-what-it.htmlIn a coincidence that seems to highlight a focus of many physicists working today, the title of Tegmark’s opening chapter --- which serves as a kind of preface for the rest of the book --- has strong parallels to the title of a book published by physicist Carlo Rovelli in the same year. (Rovelli’s book, originally in Italian, didn’t appear in English until several years later.) Tegmark’s first chapter is titled, What is Reality, and opens with the section heading Not What It Seems, while Rovelli’s book is titled Reality is Not What it Seems; both physicists make clear reference to the breakdown in our intuition as we attempt to grasp the complexity of our physical world. (My review of Rovelli’s book is linked to at left.)

Sam Harris, as part of his podcast Waking Up, has had several fascinating discussions with Tegmark, on topics ranging from the multiverse, to the future of artificial intelligence.  Links are provided below.

The Multiverse & You (& You & You & You…)
The Future of Intelligence

 

The Multiverse & You (& You & You & You…)







 The Future of Intelligence

What Is and What Matters 


What Is and What Matters
with Max Tegmark and Rebecca Goldstein



Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Saturday, May 12, 2018

Book Review: "The Late Poems of Wang An-shih"

The Late Poems of Wang An-shih (2015)
Translated from the Chinese by David Hinton

105 pages
Following the Rhymes of Pattern-Unraveled’s
Poem Here in the Small Garden


Birds no longer sing among courtyard walls and open rooms,
so much beauty, and frogs no longer call in garden pools. Now

trees cling to overnight rain, stained with autumn’s first reds,
and wildflower grasses, green as ever, flare in morning sun.

The ten thousand things, heaven’s loom of origins: there’s no
loss or gain, it’s true, but who welcomes the worry of this life?

Let’s go out, walking-sticks in hand, and gaze into all change
itself --- wondering, wondering, eyes become offerings of light. (25)

After an influential life as a government minister, the Chinese poet Wang An-shih (1021-1086) retired to a life of quiet contemplation, living in an isolated house outside River-Serene (modern day Nanjing) and journeying frequently to temples and monasteries in the nearby mountains. During these years, as he cleansed his mind of worldly concerns and embraced the profound beauty of the natural world, he wrote poetry that explored his experiences. His delicate but powerful writings, collected in The Late Poems of Wang An-shih, reflect the challenges and rewards he discovered along his spiritual path.

Wang’s poems have been translated from the Chinese by the poet David Hinton, who has also translated the works of a number of other Chinese poets. In his introduction to this volume, Hinton describes Wang as “having devoted himself to government service until the age of fifty-five, becoming one of the most powerful and controversial statesmen in Chinese history,” and that then, at the end of this career, “Wang retired to the life of a recluse poet and spent his last decade wandering among the mountains and Ch’an (Zen) Buddhist monasteries of southeast China, writing the poetry that made him one of the greatest poets in a great poetic age: the Sung Dynasty.” (xiii)

Wang reflected this biography in his poetry, which returns often to the themes of shaking off the cares of his past life in the capital city, and embracing his study of Ch’an Buddhism:
Sent to a Monk

Through ten scattered years all confusion tangled among
affairs of the world, I masked my haggard look in smiles.

If you want a mind peaceful as autumn waters, you live
your life idle as cloud drifting ranges of mountain peaks. (3)

Self-Portrait

It’s all mirage illusion, like cinnabar-and-azure paintings, this
human world. We wander here for a time, then vanish into dust.

Things aren’t other than they are. That’s all anyone can know.
Don’t ask if this thing I am today is the thing I was long ago. (16)

Wang’s appreciation for the natural beauty he finds around his isolated home, and in the nearby mountains through which he often travels, comes through in many of his poems, which include radiant descriptions of this scenery and the profound impact it has on him.
Farewell to Gaze-Arrive

Pond a scatter of emerald-green fields,
terrace a radiant riot of crimson bloom:

who can exhaust the splendor of spring?
There’s no limit to mind’s own delight. (45)
Not surprisingly, his visits back to the city during this period leave him longing ever more urgently for a quick return to the countryside:
Leaving the City

I’ve lived in the country long enough to know its wild joys:
it feels like I’m a child back home in my old village again.

Leaving the city today, I put all that gritty dust behind me,
and facing mountains and valleys, feel them enter my eyes. (39)

These references to nature also tie directly, however, to the central theme in Wang’s poetry: his dedication to a life of contemplation. As Hinton describes in the Introduction, the Ch’an Buddhist idea that “the self and its constructions of the world dissolve into the emptiness of Absence [is] a concept that recurs in Wang An-shih’s poetry.” (xvi) Wang links the recognition and appreciation of the peacefulness and apparent timelessness of the natural world, in the face of the trials and tribulations of hectic human society, to the achievement of stillness in one’s own mind.
Wandering Bell Mountain

Gazing all day into mountains, I can’t get enough of mountains.
Retire into mountains, and old age takes the form of mountains:

when mountain blossoms scatter away, mountains always remain,
and in empty mountain streamwater, mountains deepen idleness. (7)

Although I’m not able to comment on the quality of the translations, in his introduction Hinton offers a fascinating discussion on the complexity of the task. He refers to “the remarkable resources of the Chinese poetic language: its texture of imagistic clarity, pictographic script, and grammatical emptiness.” (xvi)  Selecting a particular poem, he dissects it, character by character, describing both the images portrayed within each character’s drawing, as well as the multiple meanings inherent in the character’s representation.  Along with providing an engaging insight more broadly into the Chinese language, these several pages attune readers to the depths of meaning in Wang’s poetry.

The pieces in this exquisite volume of poetry are deeply affecting, drawing in a reader with entrancing images of beauty and stillness. Crossing centuries and bridging cultural differences, Wang’s transcendent lines communicate a startlingly relevant vision of how one might look up from quotidian cares and through a recognition of the beauty in the world, discover the path to a more profound and contemplative life.
Visiting River-Serene

I’ve traveled this land five times in seven years, and at last
laugh in wonder. It’s such majesty to be alive in this world,

to become another bundle of dry grain stored up, a lone old
man somehow sharing the idleness of generations to come. (5) 


Other reviews / information:

Hinton includes a glossary of terms tied back to the poems, to explain the meanings of particular expressions, including certain location names that have modern equivalents or that were an important part of Wang’s spiritual journey, terms and concepts from Ch’an Buddhism, and references Wang made to other famous poems.

The phrase “the ten thousand things” mentioned in the poem that opens the review is a Chinese concept that also appears in a number of the other pieces in the book; as Hinton describes in the Introduction, it refers to “the empirical universe, which the ancients described as the ten thousand living and non-living things in constant transformation.” (xiv)  Author John Spurling used that expression as the title for his historical novel centered on another figure from China’s history, Wang Meng, who lived in the 1300’s, and served as a magistrate, but was also a talented artist. My review of Spurling’s novel is linked to at right.


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf

Saturday, May 5, 2018

Book Review: "Machine Learning" by Hugh Howie

Machine Learning (2017)
Hugh Howey (1975)


334 pages

Having thoroughly enjoyed author Hugh Howey’s Silo Trilogy (find my reviews of those books here: Wool, Shift, and Dust), I had high expectations for his recently issued collection of short stories, Machine Learning, in which he gathered twenty-one of his stories, most of which have been previously published in other places.

Organized into seven groups that span a range of science fiction sub-genres, the stories reflect the distinctive style that characterizes Howie’s novels, with the glint of a hard, sharp edge flashing out at a reader from the heart of each of these tightly spun tales. At the end of many of the pieces Howie has included a short note providing his recollections on the context in which the story originated. Though occasionally these vignettes can seem a bit forced, they generally give us a welcome look behind the scenes and into the mind of the author.

In the first section, Aliens and Alien Worlds, the story Second Suicide flips the framework of the typical invasion of Earth plot, telling it from the perspective of an alien soldier, a member of a force that has swept through the cosmos building up its power from the knowledge of countless, conquered civilizations that it has destroyed. With the battleships approaching Earth and planet-fall nearing, the soldier has inexplicably been transferred from a non-fighting unit into a frontline, landing group of infantry. Learning that many others have met a similar fate, his mood darkens in the face of ominous signs pointing to a challenging battle to come.

The four stories of the section Artificial Intelligence all examine the moment when an AI becomes more than its designers anticipated or even imagined possible. Glitch, for example, imagines a fighter robot designed for research into ever more advanced battle units for war that (who?) suddenly resists involvement in further fights. In Executable, a council meeting on a future Earth looks back at how the seemingly comprehensive security systems of an AI research center were compromised with devastating consequences by the creeping intelligence and connectivity gradually being introduced already now into the everyday appliances around us.

The Plagiarist, one of two stories in the section Virtual Worlds, examines the implications of the idea that we are on the verge of having computer systems capable of creating simulated worlds in which the inhabitants will not realize that they do no actually exist. The story incorporates the perhaps obvious where-does-it-end plot element for such a story, but it also examines the more subtle topic of the potentially wide variety of things that could be learned from such simulated worlds as the societies in them develop and grow in unexpected ways.

Although the stories in this collection are uniformly strong, my favorites by far are the three interlinked pieces gathered together under the heading Silo Stories, which form an extremely satisfying complement to the original Silo Trilogy. The three span the time-frame of the original books, and the surprising conclusion illustrates the enduing power of an obsessive desire for revenge, bringing to mind the quote from Melville’s Moby Dick that played a central role in another work of science fiction: “to the last I grapple with thee; from hell’s heart I stab at thee; for hate’s sake I spit my last breath at thee."

Overall, the collection of stories in Machine Learning demonstrate the ability of science fiction to move beyond the simple trope of space-operas, and in so doing exploit the genre to great effect to examine human behaviors and the implications of technology through the lens of imagined futures and alternative worlds. Howey most powerfully and effectively takes advantage of this in the stories here that look forward just a few decades into our future, examining the potentially dramatic consequences of our present-day decisions and actions.


Other reviews / information:

For more on the concept of the concept of Simulated Worlds and the potential of our existing in one: the Wikipedia entry describing the simulation hypothesis;  a Scientific American article discussing it.  Supposed proof that we are not, in Cosmos Magazine


Have you read this book, others by this author, or even similar ones by other authors? I’d enjoy hearing your thoughts.
Other of my book reviews: FICTION Bookshelf and NON-FICTION Bookshelf